water filter vs bottled water thumbnail

Water Filter vs Bottled Water Cost – Which Is More Affordable?

Everyone knows that, compared to plain tap or well water, bottled water is hundreds of times more expensive. Above that, you have to go to the store to get it which involves heavy lifting, it produces a tremendous amount of plastic waste, and some bottled water is just municipal water filled into a bottle.

And yet still, bottled water is a multi-billion dollar industry. Why? Maybe because consumers want to have certainty that the water they drink is safe, healthy and delicious.

But wait a minute; you can achieve that with the help of a water filter! And you wouldn’t have to go to the store. And there would be significantly less plastic waste. But water filter vs bottled water – which is the better choice from a cost perspective? Let’s find out!

Water Filter vs Bottled Water Cost

The Cost of Bottled Water

The U.S. bottled water industry which includes both carbonated and non-carbonated water sold in bottles or via water dispensers is a 63.6 billion dollar industry. This is how much revenue was made in the year 2018. For 2019, 67.6 billion dollars are estimated. The market is expected to grow 5.5% per year until 2023.

The volume of bottled water sold in 2018 amounted to roughly 54 billion liters, that’s about 14.27 billion gallons. Thus we get a price per liter of $1.18 USD. However, this includes both “at-home” water and “out-of-home” water. At-home covers all retail sales – think supermarkets. Out-of-home means sales to hotels, restaurants, bars, cafés, etc.

Differentiating between the two is rather important. Why? Because the price per liter for at-home water was $0.72 USD, whereas the price for out-of-home water was $4.41 USD (both for 2018), so much more expensive.

(*All numbers according to statista.com[1])

For our calculations further down below we will use $0.72 USD per liter respectively $2.73 USD per gallon as our basis unit price. Depending on which type and brand of bottled water you choose, you will pay some more or a little less.

By the way, neither flavored bottled water nor vitamin waters are part of this statistic.

lots of bottled water

The Cost of Tap/Well Water

If you have your own private well then all your household water is free, obviously. Finding a cost estimate for tap water is a little more complicated.

According to a report (Water and Wastewater Annual Price Escalation Rates for Selected Cities across the United States[2]) provided by the U.S. Department of Energy, the average (mean) rate for tap water per 1,000 gallons was $3.38 USD in 2016. This average was calculated based on the water rates of 63 selected cities across the U.S which were part of the survey. The lowest rate was about $1.00 USD (Rochester, MN) and the highest about $7.50 USD (Lubbock, TX) per 1,000 gallons.

If you currently live in Marietta, GA you will have to pay about $5.00 USD per thousand gallons. Residents of Los Altos, CA will have to pay more than $7.00 USD.

General facts:

  • Rates increased 5.09% annually between 1996 and 2018
  • Midsized water utilities have the lowest rates
  • Median rates are highest in the West and lowest in the Midwest

Why Water Rates Will Continue to Increase

It is estimated that expanding, maintaining and repairing our water infrastructure will cost us more than a trillion dollars over the next 25 years. This huge amount of money must be generated somewhere…

The Price of Purchasing, Installing & Maintaining a Water Filter

Lastly, we have to estimate the cost of purchasing, installing and maintaining (mainly filter cartridge replacements) a water filter. Now, it doesn’t make sense to try and find an overall estimate here, as this will largely vary depending on what kind of filter you are eyeballing. Instead, here is a list with standard price ranges for the most popular filter types.

We’ve also listed costs for installation and maintenance. Especially the initial financial burden of setting up a water filter can be high. That being said, a high quality product will last for many years to come. And whereas bottled water is an ongoing expense, the real savings of switching to filtered water become evident in the second year and every year after that.

Filter TypePurchase Price RangeInstallation CostAnnual Maintenance CostTotal Cost (First Year)
Reverse osmosis systems (see reviews)$150 – $500Free* – $300 (400)$60 – $200$210 – $1,000
Whole house water filters (see reviews)$300 – $1,000+Free* – $500+$100 – $300$400 – $1,800
Regular under sink filters (see reviews)$50 – $200Free* – $300$20 – $150$70 – $650
Countertop water filters (see reviews)$50 – $120$70 – $130$120 – $250
Faucet water filters (see reviews)$20 – $50$20 – $40$40 – $90
Water filter pitchers (see reviews)$20 – $50$60 – $150$80 – $200

*DIYers that are ready to take on a new project can save a few hundred bucks by installing their water filter system themselves.

Doing the Math

Alright, time do to the math!

To find out if filtered water or bottled water is more affordable we are going to do 3 examples calculations based on real-life parameters. In each case, we are going to assume that a family of 4 consumes 4 x 80 ounces = 2.5 gallons of water a day or 912.5 gallons per year. This means that the cost for bottled water for a whole year is:

912.5 bottled water gallons x $2.73 USD/gallon = $2491.13 USD

Our family would spend almost $2,500 USD on bottled water in one year.

Let’s see how well our water filters do…

Calculation Example 1: Water Filter Pitcher, Family of 4

water filter pitcher

For our first calculation example we purchase the popular Aquagear water filter pitcher which retails at around $70 USD (we know, this one is way above average) and includes 1 filter cartridge. Aquagear replacement filters cost $50 USD and last for about 150 gallons each.

The costs for 1 year of filtered water using the Aquagear pitcher are:

1. Initial purchase = $70 USD

2. # of required replacement filters: 912.5 gallons / 150 gallons = 6.08 ≈ 7

1 filter cartridge included: 7 – 1 = 6

6 x $50 USD = $300 USD

3. 5 tap water gallons ≈ $7 USD (worst case)

4. Total cost = $70 + $300 + $7 = $377 USD

In example 1, our family would spend less than $400 USD on filtered water for a whole year. For every year that follows, the annual costs would drop to $377 – $70 = $307 USD since there is no need to purchase a new filter pitcher every year.

Cost savings year 1:

$2491.13 – $377 = $2114.13 USD

Cost savings every following year:

$2491.13 – $307 = $2184.13 USD

More than 2,100 dollars in cost savings! And keep in mind that we chose one of the most expensive filter pitchers. Also, we would barely use the 6th replacement filter cartridge.

Calculation Example 2: Reverse Osmosis Under Sink System, Self-Installed, Family of 4

Reverse Osmosis System

For our next calculation example we purchase the iSpring RCC7 5-stage reverse osmosis under sink drinking water filtration system for roughly $185 USD. The first set of filters is included which should last us 1 year. Annual filter replacement costs total at $60 USD.

One more important detail is that, without an additional pump, a reverse osmosis system wastes 3 to 4 times the amount of water that you can later actually use.

The costs for 1 year of filtered water using the iSpring RCC7 reverse osmosis system are:

1. Initial purchase = $185 USD

2. 5 tap water gallons ≈ $7 USD (worst case)

3. Wastewater ≈ $7 USD x 4 = $28 USD (worst case)

4. Total cost = $185 + $7 + $28 = $220 USD

In example 2, our family would spend approximately $220 USD on reverse osmosis water for a whole year. For every year that follows, the annual costs would total $60 + $7 + $28 = $95 USD since there is no need to purchase a new RO system every year, but only the replacement filters.

Cost savings year 1:

$2491.13 – $220 = $2271.13 USD

Cost savings every following year:

$2491.13 – $307 = $2396.13 USD

Almost $2,300 USD in cost savings in the first year and nearly $2,400 USD each following year – this is simply mind blowing!

Calculation Example 3: Whole House Water Filter System, Professionally-Installed, Family of 4

big blue water filter

In our last example we buy the iSpring WGB32B-PB, a 3-stage whole house water filtration system that comes with a specialized lead reducing filter. Cost: About $450 USD for the system + $50 USD for replacement filters in the first year. To this we have to add $400 USD for the installation done by a licensed plumber. The annual filter costs starting in year 2 are $225 USD.

The costs for 1 year of filtered water are:

1. Initial purchase + replacement filter set + installation = $450 + $50 + $400 = $900 USD

2. 5 tap water gallons ≈ $7 USD (worst case)

3. Total cost = $900 + $7 = $907 USD

Our family would spend a little more than $900 USD on a professionally installed whole house water filter for lead free drinking water. For every year that follows, the annual costs would total $225 + $7 = $232 USD.

Cost savings year 1:

$2491.13 – $907 = $1584.13 USD

Cost savings every following year:

$2491.13 – $232 = $2259.13 USD

$1,584.13 USD savings in year 1 and $2259.13 USD every year after that. What’s more, we have access to filtered and more or less lead-free drinking water everywhere in our home!

Bottom Line

Looking at our calculation examples above, it becomes more than obvious that filtered water has a tremendous cost advantage over bottled water. $2,000 USD and more in potential cost savings for a family of 4 every single year – enough said!

It is also worth mentioning that the more water you drink, the sooner you will break even and the more savings you will make each year.

References:

About the Author Gene

Gene has been with BOS since the very beginning. She is head of content creation and has fully immersed herself into the home water treatment industry only to become an expert herself. Outside of BOS, Gene loves to read books on philosophy & social issues, making music, and hiking.

follow me on:

Leave a Comment: