filtration vs softening

Water Filtration vs. Softener – What’s the Difference and Which to Use When?

Some people falsely believe that, apart from producing soft water, their water softener would also protect them from harmful contaminants. Truth is, it has virtually zero effect on water quality in terms of purity.

Others are convinced that a water filter makes a great choice for treating hard water issues. Wrong again.

As there seems to be a lot of confusion about when to use a water softener and when a water filter, we are going to point out the difference between the two, and explain under what circumstances one is to be favored over the other.

The Difference Between Water Softeners and Filters

You need a new water filter? Read our reviews here. Oh, you are looking for a softening unit to solve your hard water problems? Find the best water softeners here.

Does a Water Softener Filter Water?

Hard water does not pose a health risk. Quite the contrary, its high mineral content is healthy for our bodies. This is why with water softening, the overarching goal is NOT to remove certain contaminants.

Rather, the purpose of a softening unit is primarily to prevent the build-up of limescale in your plumbing system and household appliances to protect them from premature wear out.

This can be achieved by either

  • completely removing calcium, magnesium and possibly other hardness ions with the help of a genuine salt-based water softener that accommodates a resin bed.
  • Or simply by altering the ions’ behavior to reduce their affinity to stick to surfaces, e.g. by using citric acid as a chelation agent.

The latter is also called “water conditioning“. It has the advantage that no sodium is added to your water.

Both methods will increase the lifespan and efficiency of pipes, water heaters, dishwashers, washing machines, etc. while lowering maintenance and repair costs. However, time has shown that the former is far more effective and thus the go-to approach.

Want to learn more about how a water softener works?

water softener

Also, water softeners are point-of-entry systems, meaning that they connect to the main line and soften all water in your entire home.

To answer our opening question, yes, a softener does filter water. However, “all” that is removed are hard water ions. Softeners were not designed to make water potable by filtering microorganisms, heavy metals, chlorine and other chemicals, fluoride – you name it.

ContaminantRemoval – Yes/No?
SedimentPartially, but will cause damage to system
HardnessYes
Taste & odorNo
ChlorineNo
ChemicalsNo
FluorideNo
LeadNo
Waterborne pathogensNo
Iron/rustPartially, but will cause damage to system

Do Water Filters Soften Hard Water?

Will a water filter soften your water? Not really, at least not effectively and/or efficiently enough.

However, if you are concerned about certain contaminants or impurities such as lead, mercury or pesticides for health reasons, or you simply want to improve water aesthetics, a filtration system is the right choice.

The group of water filters includes reverse osmosis (RO) systems, activated carbon (most common) and other media-type filters, and microporous filters among others.

Depending on which type you choose, contaminants get trapped in a filter e.g. by adsorption, ion exchange or micron filtration and later removed via backwashing or cartridge replacement. Or they are flushed down the drain right away.

water softener vs water filter

Whereas water softeners need to be plumbed in, the majority of filters are point-of-use devices that e.g. install under a kitchen sink or attach to a faucet. This means that they provide filtered water at a single outlet only which is why they are much smaller and less costly. (Of course there are also whole house purifiers.)

Bottom line: Especially if you use your water for drinking you should consider adding a filter system to your home. It will provide great-tasting water and protect the health of your family.

Every water softener is a water filter, but not every water filter is a water softener.

ContaminantRemoval – Yes/No? (+ Preferred Methods)
SedimentYes
HardnessPartially, but will clog filters
Taste & odorYes (carbon media)
ChlorineYes (carbon media)
ChemicalsYes (carbon media)
FluorideYes (RO or activated alumina)
LeadYes (RO or activated carbon)
Waterborne pathogensYes (RO)
Iron/rustYes

Testing Provides Answers

Water softener vs water filter – the decision as we now know depends on the condition of your water:

  • On the one hand, if it contains high levels of calcium and other minerals you are obviously dealing with hardness. A softening system is required.
  • On the other hand, if it has an unpleasant taste and odor to it, or if you face potentially harmful contaminants that better be removed, a specialized filter is needed.

A water softener protects your possessions, a water filter protects your health.

Now, to identify a hardness problem you could look for marks that hard water leaves in your home. These include stains on sinks, tubs, glasses and cutlery, scale deposits in pipes, and flaky skin and brittle hair that your family is struggling with.

In addition, excessive chlorine can easily be spotted due to its characteristic taste and smell.

However, dozens of partly dangerous contaminants that could be present in your water right now cannot be perceived with your eyes, nose or mouth. What’s more, in order for a water softener to work efficiently you need to know the exact mineral composition and concentrations.

That’s why thorough testing is the name of the game. Luckily, you don’t have to commission these tests yourself. Somebody already did that for you – for free!

Because every utility in the United States has to annually provide a quality report listing all contaminants that were found in their water the previous year. All you have to do now is find out where you receive your water from and request a copy of the latest report (not possible if you are on a private well).

Alternatively, you can have your water tested at a certified laboratory or invite a local treatment company to your home. Talking to an expert has the benefit that you can pick his brain about particular water issues. Just don’t let him talk you into buying something that you don’t want or need.

Your last option would be to pick up a kit and do the testing yourself. But this is only really recommended to measure calcium levels for hardness. DIY-testing for a broad range of contaminants lacks precision and is not economic.

Do You Need a Softener If You Have a Whole House Filter and Vice Versa?

If you struggle not only with hard water but also impurities that you want to get rid of, then the answer is yes.

The right whole house filter system supplies water safe for consumption including showering, but only reduces hardness to some extent which is not sufficient to rule out scaling.

A softener takes care of the hardness but does not supply water that meets drinking water standards.

woman drinking

So if you have the money, why not use both a softener plus a filtration system? In fact, this is pretty common among home owners.

By the way, this is also our recommended order of setup:

  1. First you have a softener that removes hardness.
  2. Then you have for example a reverse osmosis system that eliminates up to 99 percent off all impurities including the sodium that was added during the softening process. This will make your water ready for drinking.

By pre-softening the water you will also protect the delicate RO membrane at the heart of the system from fouling. The same applies to filter cartridges that contain carbon or other filter media.

Above that, adding a pre-filter before the softener is a great way to trap sediment that would otherwise accumulate in the softening system.

All in all, using a combination of both a water softener and filter is a win-win for sure!

About the Author Gene

Gene has been with BOS since the very beginning. She is head of content creation and has fully immersed herself into the home water treatment industry only to become an expert herself. Outside of BOS, Gene loves to read books on philosophy & social issues, making music, and hiking.

follow me on:

Leave a Comment: